Hermès Birkin vs Kelly: Which Iconic Bag Should You Choose?
The ultimate side-by-side guide for luxury collectors
The Origins of Two Icons
The Birkin was born in 1984 after actress Jane Birkin famously described her ideal bag to Hermès CEO Jean-Louis Dumas. The Kelly, however, has deeper roots—created in the 1930s and made famous by Grace Kelly in the 1950s.
Design Differences
Birkin
- Two top handles
- Open style with flap
- Casual elegance
- Easier access to contents
- More relaxed silhouette
Kelly
- Single top handle with shoulder strap
- Structured and formal
- Secured by clasp and flap
- More sophisticated closure
- Architectural silhouette
Which One is More Practical?
The Birkin is roomier and easier to access, making it ideal for daily use. The Kelly offers more security and a sleeker look for formal occasions but takes longer to open and close.
Investment & Resale Value
Both bags appreciate in value, but the Kelly has shown stronger resale performance in recent years, possibly due to its structured shape and crossbody versatility. However, rare Birkins in exotic skins still dominate auction records.
Sizes and Styles
| Size | Birkin | Kelly |
|---|---|---|
| 25 | Mini, perfect for evenings | Most versatile size |
| 30 | Most popular size | Elegant day bag |
| 35 | Great for work/travel | More formal look |
The Kelly also comes in two styles: Sellier (structured) and Retourne (softer edges). The Birkin is only made in Retourne style.